Skip to Content

News , Press

Andrew S. Berns Quoted In Law360 Article, “Judge Pushes To Update Arbitration Law For 21st Century”

September 27, 2021

As published by Law360, September 24, 2021
By Jeannie O’Sullivan

A Third Circuit judge has sent a strong signal that it’s time for Congress to revamp a 96-year-old federal law’s provision freeing certain transportation workers from workplace arbitration clauses, given that it lags behind in the era of phone app-based delivery work generated by Big Tech’s growing footprint.

Judge Matey’s majority opinion remanded Amazon’s arbitration bid to New Jersey district court to determine if the arbitration clause at issue is enforceable under state law, reasoning that it made sense to answer that question before delving into the discovery required to determine the scope of Section 1 as it applies to Harper.

In addition to the majority and concurrence, the decision included a dissent by U.S. Circuit Judge Patty Shwartz, who felt the district court followed the correct sequence in examining the Section 1 exemption before considering state law.

Einhorn Barbarito Frost & Botwinick PC partner Andrew S. Berns, chair of the firm’s commercial litigation and employment practices, considers the concurrence to mark the “most thorough analysis” of Section 1 that he’s seen in a long time, and only one of the few decisions containing a majority and concurrence by the same judge that he’s encountered during his 35-year career.

Click here to view article in its entirety on (Subscription required.)

Contact us to schedule a consultation or
call now to speak with an attorney 973-627-7300

Best Law Firms 2022
Best Law Firms 2020
Super Lawyers
Leading Age