Skip to Content

Einhorn, Barbarito, Frost, Botwinick, Nunn & Musmanno, PC | The contents of this website contain attorney advertising. | Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Tiffany Heineman is Counsel in the firm’s Personal Injury Department where she focuses on litigating personal injury cases of every type, including slip-and-fall and premises liability, automobile/trucking accidents, broker malpractice, construction disputes, incidents involving public entities, and other catastrophic personal injury cases.  She is an experienced trial attorney and regularly appears in courts all over the State of New Jersey and has litigated both bench trials and jury trials in a variety of civil cases.

Tiffany is also a member of New Jersey Association for Justice (NJAJ), where she regularly serves as Continuing Legal Education faculty, and speaks to other attorneys about issues and strategies in personal injury cases. She is also a Trustee of the Sussex County Bar Association.

After earning her J.D. from Seton Hall University School of Law, Tiffany served as a law clerk to the Honorable William J. McGovern, III in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division.  While a law clerk, one of her responsibilities was to serve as a Special Civil Part mediator, which instilled the importance of employing a pragmatic approach to case analysis.  Being a litigator is more than being a trial attorney but also includes the ability to settle disputes when it is appropriate and best for the client.  Throughout the span of her career, Tiffany has successfully negotiated countless matters to effective resolution.

An active participant with local community groups and legal associations, Tiffany serves as Board Chair of Girls on the Run for the New Jersey North Council. After having played tennis as an NCAA Division I athlete, she continues to play competitive tennis and platform tennis throughout New Jersey.

No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey. Click here to view recognition methodology.

Honors & Accolades

  • Thomson Reuters, Super Lawyers®
    • New Jersey Rising Stars, 2018-2025
  • Sussex County Chamber of Commerce, Young Professional of the Year Nominee, 2018 and 2019

Professional Affiliations

  • New Jersey State Bar Association – Young Lawyers Division, Member
    • Young Lawyers Division Executive Committee, 2015-2018
  • New York State Bar Association, Member
  • New Jersey Association for Justice, Member
  • Sussex County Bar Association
    • Trustee, present – 2026
    • Member; Young Lawyers Division
    • Young Lawyer’s Committee Member, 2018-2019
  • New Jersey Volunteer Lawyers for the Arts
  • Sussex County Chamber of Commerce

Community Involvement

  • Girls on the Run New Jersey North, Chair of Board of Directors (Board member 2016-present, Chair 2018-present) and provides pro bono legal guidance for the New Jersey North Council
  • Impact 100 Garden State, Grant Review Committee, 2022-present
  • Co-Coordinator of New Jersey State Bar Foundation High School Mock Trial Competition, Sussex County, 2012-2017
  • TLH Tennis New Jersey, Owner and director, 2011 – 2020
  • Salt Shakers Running Club advisory board to benefit the Sussex County Women’s Forum, 2017-2022
  • United Way Chili Open Golf Outing Planning Committee Member, 2019-2020

Articles and Presentations

• Speaker, NJAJ Winter Seminar, Store Premises Liability Cases, 2024
• Speaker, NJAJ Boardwalk webinar, Per Quod Claims in Personal Injury, 2020
• Speaker, NJAJ Winter Seminar, Premises Liability, 2019
• Speaker, NJSBA Annual Meeting and Convention, Depositions 101, 2018
• Speaker, Sussex County Bar Association, CLE seminar on Attorney Ethics, 2016
• Speaker, Sussex County Bar Association, CLE seminar on Environmental Law and Site Remediation, 2015

Settlements & Verdicts

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Call now to speak with an attorney 973-627-7300
or contact us to schedule a consultation